Maybe it is a little nuts, but it is cheap
So I actually tried making us some homemade detergent. Making it wasn’t too difficult, but then once it cooled, it separated, and I was afraid my time had been a total waste. But then I spent some more time online, and determined that I should have done this from the very beginning. I determined that it’s not usual for it to separate, but making sure the shredded soap that goes into the mixture is really, really melted is important to helping it gel rather than totally separate, and that mixing it while it cools also helps. I also determined that it’s a lot easier to deal with if you put it into a smaller container than the one I originally used, which held about 2.5 gallons of the stuff. Shaking one gallon of homemade detergent takes a little muscle, but shaking 2.5 gallons is impossible.
So now that I did all this, the question is still “Is this nuts?” After a weekend of laundry, going through all the different loads of lights, darks and whites, it seems the stuff cleans just as well as the usual concentrated all that we usually use. And if I actually keep making the stuff, buying the required borax and washing soda divides out to be way cheaper per load than buying laundry detergent from the store, even with coupons. So it’s just a question of whether it’s worth your time to track down the ingredients, shred soap with a cheese grater, mix it all up on the stove, and find a container to store your homemade detergent. For people concerned about allergens or the environment, I suppose the balance is a little different, but for me, it’s just a matter of how far you want to go to be cheap.
If you don’t think it’s so nuts, this website has a nice compilation of detergent recipes and lots of comments, which helps you navigate through concerns about separation, and the other adventures that come along with making your own detergent. Try it, if you’re totally bored on a random weekend. ;-)